All Comparisons

Propsly vs Bonusly: Which Recognition Tool is Right for You? (2025)

A detailed comparison to help you choose the best employee recognition platform for your team's needs and budget.

Quick Comparison

Feature Propsly Bonusly
Free Tier ✓ Unlimited users, forever free ✗ Free trial only
Pricing Model Free or $50/month flat ~$3/user/month
50-person team cost $0 - $50/month ~$150/month
Setup Time 30 seconds Hours to days
Slack Integration ✓ Native, Slack-only ✓ Yes
Microsoft Teams ✗ No ✓ Yes
Mobile App ✗ No (Slack mobile) ✓ Yes
Rewards Catalog ✓ Global catalog ✓ Global catalog
Analytics Basic (Free) / Advanced (Pro) ✓ Yes
G2 Rating New entrant 4.8/5 (1,400+ reviews)

Pricing Breakdown

Propsly

Free forever
  • Unlimited users at no cost
  • No credit card required
  • Full recognition features
  • Public leaderboards
  • Pro: $50/mo flat (optional)

Bonusly

~$3 /user/month
  • Per-seat pricing model
  • Free trial available
  • Teams support
  • Mobile app
  • Performance management tools

Cost example: A 100-person company would pay $0-$50/month with Propsly vs. ~$300/month with Bonusly.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Recognition Mechanics

Propsly: Simple /props slash command with monthly point allocation (200 points default). Points reset monthly to maintain scarcity and meaning.

Bonusly: Point-based recognition with customizable allowances. Points can be redeemed for rewards from a global catalog.

Platform Support

Propsly: Slack-only integration. Built specifically for teams that live in Slack - no context switching required.

Bonusly: Multi-platform support including Slack, Microsoft Teams, web app, and mobile apps for iOS and Android.

Setup & Onboarding

Propsly: 30-second setup. Click "Add to Slack," authorize, and start recognizing immediately. No training required.

Bonusly: 4-6 week implementation timeline for larger deployments. More configuration options but requires more setup time.

Analytics & Reporting

Propsly: Basic analytics on free tier, advanced engagement metrics and recognition patterns on Pro tier.

Bonusly: AI-powered recognition insights, comprehensive manager dashboards, and advanced analytics included.

Which Tool is Right for You?

Choose Bonusly if you...

  • Need multi-platform support (Teams + Slack)
  • Want a mature rewards catalog with gift cards
  • Require AI-powered analytics from day one
  • Want a mobile app for on-the-go recognition
  • Need performance management integration

Choose Propsly if you...

  • Want to start free with unlimited users
  • Are a Slack-first team
  • Value simplicity over feature complexity
  • Need to get started in minutes, not weeks
  • Prefer predictable pricing ($0 or $50/mo)

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I migrate from Bonusly to Propsly?

Yes! Since Propsly focuses on ongoing recognition rather than historical data, you can start fresh with Propsly at any time. Simply install the Slack app and your team can begin using it immediately alongside or instead of Bonusly.

Is Propsly really free forever?

Yes. Propsly's free tier includes unlimited users, full recognition features, and public leaderboards with no time limit. The optional Pro tier ($50/month flat) adds advanced analytics, reward automation, and priority support.

What if my team uses both Slack and Microsoft Teams?

Currently, Propsly is Slack-only. If your team primarily uses Microsoft Teams, Bonusly would be a better fit. We recommend Propsly for teams that live in Slack and want a native, focused experience.

Does Propsly have a rewards catalog like Bonusly?

Propsly's Pro tier includes automated rewards through gift cards. While our catalog isn't as extensive as Bonusly's, it covers the most popular options. For teams focused purely on peer recognition without monetary rewards, our free tier is ideal.

Ready to try Propsly?

Start building a culture of recognition today. Free for teams of any size, no credit card required.

Add to Slack - It's Free